Browse: Home / Antonin Scalia and the Republican Gamble

Menu

Skip to content
Header image

Stony Brook IndependentLogo

Stony Brook University News

Menu

Skip to content
  • News
    • Health & Science
    • Sports
  • Reviews
    • Movie Review
    • Music Review
  • Blogs
  • Listicles
  • The Howler
    • WUSB In Focus
    • Indie Air
    • WUSB News-at-Noon
    • INDIE-TV
  • About Us
    • Staff Bios
    • Newsletter
    • Subscribe
    • Advertising
    • Send Us A Tip
  • Top 10 Spring Break Destinations For College Students
  • Your Brookfest 2016 Artists Are...
  • Black History Month Closing Ceremony Sends Message Of Resilience
  • 10 Facts You Didn't Know About Primaries, Caucuses
  • Jeb Bush Drops Out Of The Election
Screen Shot 2016-02-17 at 5.52.12 PM

Antonin Scalia and the Republican Gamble

Posted by Janelle Clausen on February 19, 2016 in Blogs | 45 Views | Leave a response

Photo from Shawn/Flickr

By Janelle Clausen
Staff Writer

Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia had barely passed away when a depressingly despicable partisan firestorm emerged.

Republicans are pushing against President Obama nominating a replacement, but there’s nothing in the Constitution that says the President can’t nominate anyone in his last year.

Article II of the U.S. Constitution simply grants the President the responsibility of nominating justices to serve on this highest court of the land, with the advice and consent of the Senate.

Antonin Scalia, despite being notoriously conservative, was unanimously approved by the Senate in 1986. Ruth Bader Ginsburg was approved 96-3 in 1993, despite her well-known work with the American Civil Liberties Union.

The point I’m making is this: Partisanship really shouldn’t be an issue in this. But it is, and a lot is at stake this election year.

Scalia was a conservative icon fairly often sided with the right side of the Supreme Court. This usually meant a 5-4 split on ideological issues, with the libertarian Justice Kennedy being the swing vote.

Now it’s completely even, and a tie vote effectively upholds lower court rulings. This could keep things like affirmative action and the power of unions intact— for now. President Obama appointing a liberal justice would tip this balance, likely for a few years.

Unified opposition to nominating a Justice isn’t unheard of. But if the Republicans blocked the nominations until Obama’s term ends on Jan. 20, 2017, it’d be the second longest time with a Supreme Court vacancy, the longest vacancy being 391 days. It’s gross, but not unprecedented.

It’s also a gamble that might be worth taking.

If a Republican president is somehow elected, they could end up appointing multiple justices. It’s probable that Ruth Bader Ginsburg could pass away, given her age and previous health issues. Stephen Breyer, another Bill Clinton appointee, also isn’t very young anymore. In their absolute best case scenario, Kagan and Sotomayor could be the only liberals left on the court.

That’s a 7-2 split that would likely rule against unions, environmental controls, market regulation, reproductive rights and affirmative action- all the things Democratics hold dear. Further challenges to the Affordable Care Act could see its complete dismantlement rather than its survival. Freedom, the Republicans would say, would finally reign.

And, at the very least, conservatives could retain their majority on the Supreme Court by appointing a younger Antonin Scalia.

(Want to read more about ideology’s impact on the Supreme Court? I’ve got another blog for that.) 

But of course, this could all blow back in their face. The American people could see Republicans as obstructionist jerks and vote them out of numerous legislative seats, not to mention elect another Democratic president. Then you’d likely have a super liberal from a Sanders or Clinton administration and a favorable vote for the aforementioned issues.

In short, it’s high risk/high reward for the Republicans. It’s not clear yet who will win the election. Maybe Marco Rubio can recover and defeat Clinton, continuing a pattern of switching parties every two terms or so. Maybe Donald Trump will surprise us all and somehow win. Maybe Ted Cruz can get his courageous conservatives to actually get out and vote. That is, after all, key in any election.  

What’s clear, however, is that it speaks very poorly of us as the United States of America. Our nation is more polarized between the political left and right than ever. The touching friendship shared between Ruth Bader Ginsburg (a liberal) and Antonin Scalia (a conservative) is now a foreign entity. As things are now, there can be no compromise.

Posted in Blogs | Tagged 2016, antonin scalia, Democrats, dummies guide to the campaign, national politics, partisanship, rbg, Republicans, Stony Brook Independent, Stony Brook University, Supreme Court

About the Author

Janelle Clausen

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related Posts

12418888_1095914847109628_7499244681555027926_oYour Brookfest 2016 Artists Are…→

Yusef Salaam: When I see young people I see the next president of US Photo by Lawrence NzuveBlack History Month Closing Ceremony Sends Message Of Resilience→

Two guys in golf cart: 'You didn't get out and vote?' - 'Are you kidding me.....?'10 Facts You Didn’t Know About Primaries, Caucuses→

rsz_jebJeb Bush Drops Out Of The Election→

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Advertisement

WUSB News-at-Noon

Featured Video

  • Latest
  • Top Rated
  • Trending
  • tumblr_m57h05LC4g1r714xso1_500

    Top 10 Spring Break Destinations For College Students

    March 4, 2016 / rawsonjahan
  • 12418888_1095914847109628_7499244681555027926_o

    Your Brookfest 2016 Artists Are…

    March 2, 2016 / jrcole
  • Yusef Salaam: When I see young people I see the next president of US Photo by Lawrence Nzuve

    Black History Month Closing Ceremony Sends Message Of Resilience

    March 2, 2016 / lawrencenzuve
  • Two guys in golf cart: 'You didn't get out and vote?' - 'Are you kidding me.....?'

    10 Facts You Didn’t Know About Primaries, Caucuses

    March 1, 2016 / jennifercooper
  • rsz_jeb

    Jeb Bush Drops Out Of The Election

    February 29, 2016 / jennifercooper
  • admin-ajax.php-2

    On Kylie Minogue’s New Album, “Kiss Me Once” Was All She Said

  • Divergent-Movie-640x360

    ‘Divergent’ Hits its Mark

  • Captain-America-The-Winter-Soldier1

    7 Reasons To Watch Captain America: The Winter Soldier

  • bbc

    Bombay Bicycle Club Is Back With A Bang

  • Need for Speed Poster

    ‘Need for Speed’ Tries Hard, Misses Finish Line

Advertisement

Subscribe

Want everything to just be sent right to you? Sign up for our newsletter. Don't forget to check your spam. Thanks!

Contact Us!

Like what you see? Or don't? Either way, let us know during our weekly general meetings on Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. Or drop by during our weekly workshops Thursday nights at 7 p.m.

We're located in room 072 in the Student Union Building on Stony Brook University.

For more info, email [email protected] with questions, concerns or qualms.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
 

Advertisement

advertisement
 

Advertisment

advertisement
 

Follow us on Twitter

My Tweets
 

©2015 Stony Brook Independent

Menu

  • Send Us A Tip